A lot of ink has been spilled in recent days over whether or not Trump is a racist. I want to contend, perhaps controversially, that it doesn't matter. And, in fact, that arguing over whether or not he (or anyone else) is racist doesn't serve those of us who are deeply concerned about this kind of discourse. It doesn't serve us, not because what he's saying isn't racist, but precisely because it is. And this is where the distinction between intent and impact really matters.
I'm a linguist (I may have mentioned this before). And, in fact, I'm a linguistic anthropologist. So you might say that my stock in trade is based in the understanding that speech* is action. To say something is to do something in the world. (Maybe reread that, because it's the foundation of the whole rest of this post.)
What this means is that we are not responsible only for what we mean by our words, but also for what they do. I understand that this is the point where all of us, including me, to one degree or another, feel resistance. But surely I can't be responsible for all of the possible impacts of my words - what about people who are hypersensitive? What about stuff I didn't know could be hurtful? Why can't people give me the benefit of the doubt? And I get it. I truly do.
That doesn't change the fact that our words have an impact. And the more that those words ring with broader discourses and social structures that create and reinforce inequalities, the more we are responsible for their impacts. A useful term here is "intertextuality", the idea that every text (spoken texts count) is understood in no small part through its links to other texts, past and present. No speech event stands in isolation.
I think it also helps to unpack what it means to say that a particular speech event is racist (or sexist, or misogynist, and so on). (I should say before I go on that there's really no way to cover this well in a space this short - this is a massive national conversation we need to be having - and I was tempted to say nothing at all, but I think that way lies complicity, so here I go.) A racist speech event is one that upholds and justifies the structures which legitimate one group of people's ways of being and doing as right and natural for our society as a whole.**
As a relevant aside, I have been struck by the many people who are upset by those who criticize what they call "our" way of life. Who is the "we" there? It is white, Christian, and patriarchal. The use of "our" is another racist speech event that upholds those identities as normative, right, legitimate. And it simultaneously denigrates anyone who would hold alternative perspectives.***
A racist speech event is about power. It upholds the power, in this country, of white folks to say what they want; it upholds and justifies the structures that allow that to happen. It upholds and legitimizes the violences that keep people of color from speaking (physical, emotional, psychological, political, and so on). A single speech event, through the process of intertextuality, draws upon and feeds the many other speech events that create a system of racism in this country. In other words, speech doesn't just reflect what is, it creates it in an ongoing way. It reifies structures - makes them real. As fiber artists (which I know many of you are), we know that a single strand of yarn may be weak, but a knitted or woven structure is strong. In the same way, a single speech event, all by itself, may not seem strong - but we must acknowledge and understand that each speech event is interwoven with many many others. And that interweaving makes them strong. It creates impact.
I started this off by saying that it doesn't really matter if Trump is a racist (and boy, am I having trouble not also writing this about misogyny). And here's why. When someone says that he (or anyone else who says something that justifies and reinforces structures of racism) is a racist, it's all too easy to duck that charge, as we are seeing here. And then we get into arguments about whether a person really is racist. (Check out this video, which I show my students each semester - Jay Smooth gets at this point in a fun and useful way.) But it doesn't really matter whether someone is racist in their heart of hearts. Instead, it's critical to focus on what their words are actually doing out there in the world. As many have argued in their analyses of the implications of telling four women of color, all US citizens (and three of whom were born here in the US), to go home if they are going to criticize anything about the US, these words do a number of things out there in the world, all of them racist. They say that some people are allowed to criticize the US, and others aren't. I'd like to point out that no-one has told Bernie Sanders to go home. Or Elizabeth Warren. That is a text (silence is also a text) which links to this one, and tells us that white folks (and especially white men) can engage in criticism of the US, but that women of color cannot. These words tell us which folks can become US citizens, and whose membership in our national community, no matter how long they've been here, is contingent. Barring Native Americans, we all came here from somewhere - some of us willingly, others as enslaved human beings. No-one ever, not ever, tells white men to go home. Their immigrant status is gone in a generation. People of color do not get that consideration. (This chimes with the birther lies about President Obama, which only make sense if the citizenship of people of color is always contingent.)
Even Lindsay Graham's statement reinforces this message: "I don't think [Trump's statement] is racist to say. I don't think a Somali refugee embracing Trump would be asked to go back. If you're racist, you want everybody to go back because they are black or Muslim." It is not true to say that if you're racist, you'd want everybody to back. Racism is about maintaining systems of inequality. Insisting that people of color are OK as long as they agree with you is, you guessed it, part of a system of inequality. It relies on and replicates racism.
I know from teaching about this in my classes that it's
really hard to step into the idea that our words are implicated in
immense and intractable structures of racism and misogyny. It feels too
big. I think we end up feeling frightened by the weight of
responsibility that this implies, and when we're frightened, we often
get angry (so much easier to feel righteous indignation than fear and
shame). As I try to help my students see (and as I try to remember
myself), the fact that our words have so much power should give us not
only pause and an incentive to be careful, but also hope. If my words can reinforce structures of
power inequity, institutionalized forms of violence, surely they can
also help to undo them? At the very least, I have the power to choose
not to make real the things that I don't want to see in the world.
When
someone calls us out on the impact of our words, and we respond by
saying things like, "but I didn't mean it that way", or "why are you so
sensitive?", we are speaking from and defending our smaller selves.
When we say, "but I didn't know" that it would have that impact, or that
it does that thing out there in the world, that is true sometimes. It
seems, though, that once we know better, we can do better. Not out of a
sense of self-flagellation or martyrdom, but rather because there's
something important about being actively engaged in creating the world
we want to live in. Something that speaks to our larger Selves, the selves that understand that we live in community, that interconnection makes us better. Bringing about Martin Luther King Jr's Beloved
Community, a world where we can look at one another and see ourselves in all other beings -
it doesn't happen in isolation. It doesn't happen if we indulge in
guilt or shame, or if we hide from the consequences of our actions. And
it certainly doesn't happen without care for our words, precisely
because they are action.
*"Speech" is (not unproblematic) shorthand for language in both its primary - oral and manual (signed) - and secondary (written) forms.
**Please note: this is why reverse racism really isn't a thing. Even if
individual people are biased against white folks, they don't have the
structures of power behind them, and their bias doesn't create
structures of power which disadvantage white folks. I know that it's
tempting to think that they do, but the data show otherwise.
*** Please also note: to believe that this was, at any point in its past, a white nation is to disregard the facts of history. Our history books have been written to give that impression. Which, of course, implicates those books in this project of upholding racial inequities. This is also why it's problematic to say that people of color (and women, and LGBTQ folks, etc) are playing "identity politics". We're all playing identity politics - it's just that white, Christian, male identities are allowed to remain unspoken, so when policies are put in place that benefit that particular group, we call that business as usual.
Friday, July 19, 2019
Thursday, July 18, 2019
Day 8: Connecting
On the way to an appointment this afternoon, driving along the Coast Highway with the top down, I got a call saying that they were running about 15 minutes late. As it was, I was going to be early. So I pulled off, got out of the car, and sat myself down on a flat spot to watch the ocean for a while. It's a perfect day - clear, 80, onshore breeze. And I just sat, enjoying the sun, and the breeze, and the expanse of the ocean in front of me.
There are ground squirrels everywhere in the bluffs that overlook the coast - they run around and play and chitter at one another. There came a point when I looked over to my left and saw, sitting there just quietly, a ground squirrel. She was up on her hind legs, front paws resting on her belly, gazing out at the ocean, completely at peace.
I was moved by such a heartfelt sense of deep connection - there we were, two busy beings, taking a moment out of our days to regard beauty, to sit quietly with the world.
Before I left, I bowed to her presence, which so enriched my own.
There are ground squirrels everywhere in the bluffs that overlook the coast - they run around and play and chitter at one another. There came a point when I looked over to my left and saw, sitting there just quietly, a ground squirrel. She was up on her hind legs, front paws resting on her belly, gazing out at the ocean, completely at peace.
I was moved by such a heartfelt sense of deep connection - there we were, two busy beings, taking a moment out of our days to regard beauty, to sit quietly with the world.
Before I left, I bowed to her presence, which so enriched my own.
Wednesday, July 17, 2019
Day 7: Who needs to "go back"?
This has been coming to mind over the last few days, so I thought I'd post, as it makes me laugh in a dark and sassy kind of way...
A slightly different perspective on belonging and respect, in response to this week's deeply problematic twit storm:
A slightly different perspective on belonging and respect, in response to this week's deeply problematic twit storm:
Tuesday, July 16, 2019
Day 6: Food for thought
Context: I am currently about six months into a two-year mindfulness meditation teacher certification program. So much more to say, but I'll leave it at that for now.
A quote from the book Science Set Free (Rupurt Sheldrake), talking about the ideas of the mathematician and philosopher Alfred North Whitehead:
"Reality consists of moments in process, and one moment informs the next. The distinction between moments requires the experiencer to feel the difference between the moment of now and past or future moments. Every actuality is a moment of experience. As it expires and becomes a past moment, it is succeeded by a new moment of "now", a new subject of experience. Meanwhile the moment that has just expired becomes a past object for the new subject."
That really describes one of the insights offered by meditation - that reality is just the rising and falling of right-now experience, and that the moment of now feeds into and creates the next moment of now, just as it was created by past moments of now. Interesting...
A quote from the book Science Set Free (Rupurt Sheldrake), talking about the ideas of the mathematician and philosopher Alfred North Whitehead:
"Reality consists of moments in process, and one moment informs the next. The distinction between moments requires the experiencer to feel the difference between the moment of now and past or future moments. Every actuality is a moment of experience. As it expires and becomes a past moment, it is succeeded by a new moment of "now", a new subject of experience. Meanwhile the moment that has just expired becomes a past object for the new subject."
That really describes one of the insights offered by meditation - that reality is just the rising and falling of right-now experience, and that the moment of now feeds into and creates the next moment of now, just as it was created by past moments of now. Interesting...
Monday, July 15, 2019
Day 5: Twenty-five years
Twenty-five years ago today, we had a party to celebrate and to say in front of everyone all the things that we already knew about each other and our relationship.
(All photos of photographs; who knows where the negatives now are?)
Twenty-five years later, and there are still so many things to celebrate together. My life is so much richer and happier because of this man and our relationship. Love you, babe.
(Credit for this last one: GerrBear Photography)
Sunday, July 14, 2019
Day 4: Singular they
A propos of yesterday's post...
The New York Times recently published an interesting opinion piece about the use of singular "they". It was especially interesting to me because the author proposes doing something that I have considered doing - using "they" for everyone, as the default singular third-person* pronoun. (The reasons why I don't think this is an unproblematic suggestion are a post for another day.)
It's worth backing up here and saying that I naturally think about pronouns and gender. Because a) I'm a linguist (see the title of the blog); b) I teach a language and gender class; c) my daughters both have friends who identify as gender fluid, some of whom maintain their original gendered pronouns, others of whom prefer "they"; d) to my own surprise, I find myself struggling to use "they" to refer to a specific singular human being (although I have no trouble whatsoever using "they" to refer to a non-specified singular human being, and find the arguments that "they" can only be used with a plural antecedent specious, see more below). It's the combination of those things that attracts my attention, in the form of - hunh, I wonder what's going on there? I have, in the past, had relatively little trouble when friends (or friends of the girls) change their preferred names. After some mistakes, I usually settle into the new name fairly quickly. I am definitely of the opinion that people should get to decide what they're called, whether as individuals or groups - naming is a form of power, and the protests of the dominant group that they can't keep up with the preferred names of non-dominant groups is a way of maintaining power. Any time someone protests over something like a name change, or a particular way that language is used, it's time to start looking at power structures. (When someone says, what's the big deal with me using X label to refer to you, instead of your preferred Y? I always want to say, if it's not such a big deal, why not just do it? The answer is because it is a big deal - naming is power, and the right to name is a way of asserting power.) So what the heck is it that makes it so difficult for me to remember that my daughter's friend is "they" rather than "she"?
In response to the article, I posted the following**:
As a linguist who teaches about language and gender, I have always found the insistence that “they” shouldn’t be used to refer to a single person problematic, in the sense that such a rule doesn’t describe what many people actually do with language*** - which is to use “they/them” to refer to singular, unknown or unspecified people. We do this all the time, and to suggest that it’s confusing or ungrammatical to say “Everyone should turn in their homework now” doesn’t accurately capture reality. The place where I have unexpectedly found myself struggling is when referring to a known and specific human being as “they”. My sense is that this is difficult for me precisely because, in my mental grammar, “they” encodes a nonspecific person; I don’t think I’m alone. Nor do I think that this is immutable - we change the way we speak all the time. Grammatical elements of language (pronouns, in this case) are more difficult to change, but not impossible. As a relevant case in point, consider our second-person pronoun, “you”. Historically, “you” was our plural pronoun, while “thee/thou” was the singular. I don’t think anyone would argue now that it’s confusing to say “you should come to dinner” - even though sometimes it is (do you mean me? Or my whole family?). We negotiate those confusions in other ways [e.g., the addition of y'all to our lexicon; and when y'all, in some dialects, came to refer to singular human beings, the further addition of all y'all]. So there is no reason why our pronominal system can’t absorb a similar change in the third person. And many reasons why it should.
I've been mulling this over more since then. Someone posted a question on my comment, saying that they thought that "thee/thou" was like Spanish "usted", that is, a formal pronoun, which caused me to confirm my assertion (I was correct; here's an interesting summary). Basically, the pronoun "you", once simply a second-person plural pronoun, came to have a pragmatic function of also indicating respect, or of denoting a relationship between strangers (as "vous" does in French). "Thee", over time, began to fall out of usage, except in intimate relationships in some dialects. But it had already been encoded in the King James Bible, and in poetry, and so began to take on an additional pragmatic function as a marker of religious or poetic language, which is probably why the person who commented thought it meant the formal (when, in fact, in the Bible and poetry, it was simply marking the singular). Summary: pronouns can come to mean more than simply first/second/third person singular/plural; they can also denote social relationships or roles. When those additional denotations become the dominant meaning in the mental grammars of speakers, then language changes.
The idea that we can't use "they" to refer to a specific, single, human being because it's ungrammatical or confusing just doesn't square with the evidence. But it does square with the kinds of language ideologies that we use to police non-dominant groups. And it does square with a strong belief that we shouldn't have to be uncomfortable when we speak - an idea that is only true for the dominant group (non-dominant groups in any given setting live with discomfort when they speak). I tend to think that discomfort is important - it tells us when hidden norms and values are being challenged, and gives us an opportunity to look at them head-on, and to ask, whose values and norms? To whose benefit/loss? And, where do I stand?
* Just for those who don't swim around in grammar all the time, some definitions. First person refers to the speaker (in English, I/me/we/us). Second person refers to the the addressee - the person or people being spoken to (therefore, the second people in a conversation)(in English, you). And third person (as I always say to my students) refers to the spoken-about (she/her/he/him/they/them).
** I am not one of those folks who leaves comments all the time - I very rarely do. I also very rarely read comments, because they usually just annoy the crap out of me. As my comment probably did to some other poor soul who chose to read it.
*** Linguistics is the study of what people actually do with language. In other words, we describe real-world language use, rather than prescribing how language ought to be used. A linguistic anthropologist, such as myself, might look at ideologies around how language "should" be used as an object of study, but our field is not focused on grammatical nitpicking. That is not to say that we don't all have our pet peeves around language use - but when we are being professional, we know that those are ideologies/opinions, rather than true statements about grammar; the question of "good" versus "bad" language is not a linguistic one. I often wish more people knew this, because as soon as I say I'm a linguist in any social gathering, people find some excuse to wander off and never talk in front of me again. Little do they know that, rather than judging, I am listening carefully so I can gather data! (mwahaha)
The New York Times recently published an interesting opinion piece about the use of singular "they". It was especially interesting to me because the author proposes doing something that I have considered doing - using "they" for everyone, as the default singular third-person* pronoun. (The reasons why I don't think this is an unproblematic suggestion are a post for another day.)
It's worth backing up here and saying that I naturally think about pronouns and gender. Because a) I'm a linguist (see the title of the blog); b) I teach a language and gender class; c) my daughters both have friends who identify as gender fluid, some of whom maintain their original gendered pronouns, others of whom prefer "they"; d) to my own surprise, I find myself struggling to use "they" to refer to a specific singular human being (although I have no trouble whatsoever using "they" to refer to a non-specified singular human being, and find the arguments that "they" can only be used with a plural antecedent specious, see more below). It's the combination of those things that attracts my attention, in the form of - hunh, I wonder what's going on there? I have, in the past, had relatively little trouble when friends (or friends of the girls) change their preferred names. After some mistakes, I usually settle into the new name fairly quickly. I am definitely of the opinion that people should get to decide what they're called, whether as individuals or groups - naming is a form of power, and the protests of the dominant group that they can't keep up with the preferred names of non-dominant groups is a way of maintaining power. Any time someone protests over something like a name change, or a particular way that language is used, it's time to start looking at power structures. (When someone says, what's the big deal with me using X label to refer to you, instead of your preferred Y? I always want to say, if it's not such a big deal, why not just do it? The answer is because it is a big deal - naming is power, and the right to name is a way of asserting power.) So what the heck is it that makes it so difficult for me to remember that my daughter's friend is "they" rather than "she"?
In response to the article, I posted the following**:
As a linguist who teaches about language and gender, I have always found the insistence that “they” shouldn’t be used to refer to a single person problematic, in the sense that such a rule doesn’t describe what many people actually do with language*** - which is to use “they/them” to refer to singular, unknown or unspecified people. We do this all the time, and to suggest that it’s confusing or ungrammatical to say “Everyone should turn in their homework now” doesn’t accurately capture reality. The place where I have unexpectedly found myself struggling is when referring to a known and specific human being as “they”. My sense is that this is difficult for me precisely because, in my mental grammar, “they” encodes a nonspecific person; I don’t think I’m alone. Nor do I think that this is immutable - we change the way we speak all the time. Grammatical elements of language (pronouns, in this case) are more difficult to change, but not impossible. As a relevant case in point, consider our second-person pronoun, “you”. Historically, “you” was our plural pronoun, while “thee/thou” was the singular. I don’t think anyone would argue now that it’s confusing to say “you should come to dinner” - even though sometimes it is (do you mean me? Or my whole family?). We negotiate those confusions in other ways [e.g., the addition of y'all to our lexicon; and when y'all, in some dialects, came to refer to singular human beings, the further addition of all y'all]. So there is no reason why our pronominal system can’t absorb a similar change in the third person. And many reasons why it should.
I've been mulling this over more since then. Someone posted a question on my comment, saying that they thought that "thee/thou" was like Spanish "usted", that is, a formal pronoun, which caused me to confirm my assertion (I was correct; here's an interesting summary). Basically, the pronoun "you", once simply a second-person plural pronoun, came to have a pragmatic function of also indicating respect, or of denoting a relationship between strangers (as "vous" does in French). "Thee", over time, began to fall out of usage, except in intimate relationships in some dialects. But it had already been encoded in the King James Bible, and in poetry, and so began to take on an additional pragmatic function as a marker of religious or poetic language, which is probably why the person who commented thought it meant the formal (when, in fact, in the Bible and poetry, it was simply marking the singular). Summary: pronouns can come to mean more than simply first/second/third person singular/plural; they can also denote social relationships or roles. When those additional denotations become the dominant meaning in the mental grammars of speakers, then language changes.
The idea that we can't use "they" to refer to a specific, single, human being because it's ungrammatical or confusing just doesn't square with the evidence. But it does square with the kinds of language ideologies that we use to police non-dominant groups. And it does square with a strong belief that we shouldn't have to be uncomfortable when we speak - an idea that is only true for the dominant group (non-dominant groups in any given setting live with discomfort when they speak). I tend to think that discomfort is important - it tells us when hidden norms and values are being challenged, and gives us an opportunity to look at them head-on, and to ask, whose values and norms? To whose benefit/loss? And, where do I stand?
* Just for those who don't swim around in grammar all the time, some definitions. First person refers to the speaker (in English, I/me/we/us). Second person refers to the the addressee - the person or people being spoken to (therefore, the second people in a conversation)(in English, you). And third person (as I always say to my students) refers to the spoken-about (she/her/he/him/they/them).
** I am not one of those folks who leaves comments all the time - I very rarely do. I also very rarely read comments, because they usually just annoy the crap out of me. As my comment probably did to some other poor soul who chose to read it.
*** Linguistics is the study of what people actually do with language. In other words, we describe real-world language use, rather than prescribing how language ought to be used. A linguistic anthropologist, such as myself, might look at ideologies around how language "should" be used as an object of study, but our field is not focused on grammatical nitpicking. That is not to say that we don't all have our pet peeves around language use - but when we are being professional, we know that those are ideologies/opinions, rather than true statements about grammar; the question of "good" versus "bad" language is not a linguistic one. I often wish more people knew this, because as soon as I say I'm a linguist in any social gathering, people find some excuse to wander off and never talk in front of me again. Little do they know that, rather than judging, I am listening carefully so I can gather data! (mwahaha)
Saturday, July 13, 2019
Day 3: Pride
My younger daughter and her friend went downtown today to celebrate in San Diego's Pride parade and festival.
Question: Why is San Diego's Pride celebration in July instead of June?
Question: Is this a metaphor?
Question: Or is it a kind of cool way to remind us that none of these X Month celebrations should ever be restricted to just one month?
(Or maybe both?)
By happenstance, I had the opportunity to indulge my inner magpie with an unplanned stop at a yarn store sighted in Bellingham (while taking my niece to visit WWU; no, yarn stores were not meant to be on the itinerary). But the logo for Northwest Yarns is an octopus holding knitting needles - I had to go in, right? I may have walked away with a few things (but not the Majacraft Little Gem that I have long coveted - good for me, right?), including (speaking of Pride) this lovely braid:
which is destined to become something warm for my daughter to wear this winter in Seattle, where she'll be a freshman at Seattle U. I really should be working on her college blanket (ahem), but I am trying to spin a little bit each day while we watch the Tour de France.
I'm actually done with the red and orange and am into the yellow. This will be chain-plied to preserve the nice long color changes. Knitters out there, any recommendations for something in the neck-warming realm that would show this off suitably?
Question: Why is San Diego's Pride celebration in July instead of June?
Question: Is this a metaphor?
Question: Or is it a kind of cool way to remind us that none of these X Month celebrations should ever be restricted to just one month?
(Or maybe both?)
By happenstance, I had the opportunity to indulge my inner magpie with an unplanned stop at a yarn store sighted in Bellingham (while taking my niece to visit WWU; no, yarn stores were not meant to be on the itinerary). But the logo for Northwest Yarns is an octopus holding knitting needles - I had to go in, right? I may have walked away with a few things (but not the Majacraft Little Gem that I have long coveted - good for me, right?), including (speaking of Pride) this lovely braid:
which is destined to become something warm for my daughter to wear this winter in Seattle, where she'll be a freshman at Seattle U. I really should be working on her college blanket (ahem), but I am trying to spin a little bit each day while we watch the Tour de France.
I'm actually done with the red and orange and am into the yellow. This will be chain-plied to preserve the nice long color changes. Knitters out there, any recommendations for something in the neck-warming realm that would show this off suitably?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






